condition, criterion, cause and effect
The four parts of a well-written audit finding: what was found, the rule it breaks, why it happened, and what could go wrong as a result.
In more detail
The condition is the evidence of what actually happened, such as two of fifteen sampled changes approved by the person who made them. The criterion is the policy clause, standard or control statement that sets the expected behaviour. The cause explains why the gap occurred, which points to the right fix, and the effect states the risk in terms management cares about. Management then responds with an owner, a corrective action and a date, and the finding stays open until a retest confirms the fix.
Example
Condition: 2 of 15 sampled changes broke the approval rule; Criterion: the change policy clause; Cause: the tool allows self-approval and approval after closure; Effect: an unreviewed change could reach productionRelated terms
- finding — A documented result of an audit or assessment that shows where something does not meet the requirement it was checked against.
- management response — Management's written answer to an audit finding, stating what will be fixed, by whom and by when.
- evidence — The records, files and outputs that show a control really exists and works, collected so that someone else can check it.
- retest — Checking a control again after a fix to confirm the problem is really gone before a finding is closed.
Taught in
- Privacy Principles, GDPR Subject Rights & Minimization — Cybersecurity Fundamentals, GRC & Cryptography
- Internal Audits, Sampling & Evidence Chains — Cybersecurity Fundamentals, GRC & Cryptography